Cast
School Attorney Amy Ryan Superintendent Jim Powell Reverend Jude Richard Thawley Waiter Rice Broocks Susan Stone Mrs. Rizzo Rev. Dave Double First Teacher Jessica Goth Girl Crazy Cat Lady Frazzled Teacher Fashionista Gary Habermas Sunny Barista Salvation Army Lady Mike Huckabee Bailiff County Clerk Slacker Kid Prospective Juror Male Journalist Simon Boyle Paramedic Norma V.P. of Teachers Union Teenage Girl Pharmacist Female Juror Elizabeth Healy Older Man Lee Strobel Jury Forman Jim Warner Wallace Martin's Father The Newsboys The Newsboys The Newsboys Concert Patron, not listed in creditsа Jury Extra, not listed in credits Medical Staff, not listed in credits Food Truck Patron, not listed in creditsа Gallery Observer, not listed in creditsа Lawyer, not listed in credits Waitress, not listed in creditsа Extra, not listed in creditsа Courtroom Observer, not listed in creditsа Student (trouble maker), not listed in credits Protester Shaking Jesse Metcalfe Hand, not listed in credits Supporter, not listed in creditsа Juror #6, not listed in credits Background, not listed in credits Courtroom Observer / Protester, not listed in creditsа Courtroom Observer, not listed in creditsа Courtroom Gallery / Protestor, not listed in creditsа Courtroom Observer / Reporter, not listed in credits Concert patron, not listed in creditsа Protester, not listed in creditsа Concert Attendee, not listed in credits Concert Patron, not listed in creditsа Lawyer Assistant, not listed in credits Extra, not listed in creditsа Reporter, not listed in creditsа Concert Patron, not listed in creditsа Extra, not listed in credits